7 Best Gutter Companies in Stillwater, MN (2026 Guide)

Gutters in Stillwater are an unusually nuanced project for a city its size. Inside the historic preservation overlay, the gutter profile, the downspout placement, and even the paint color can affect HPC review — half-round copper or painted aluminum on a contributing 1880s home is not the same conversation as 6-inch K-style aluminum on a 2003 home in Liberty on the Lake. Outside the overlay, Stillwater’s bluff-edge geography and heavy mature-tree cover make gutter sizing and downspout discharge harder than they look. Original 5-inch K-style gutters on a 1995 split-level overflow regularly during a real summer storm, and the water has a long way to run downhill once it does.

This guide ranks the seven best gutter companies serving Stillwater, MN. We’ve cut the chains that subcontract everything, the storm-chasers, and the LeafGuard-only outfits that refuse to discuss anything but their own branded product. What’s left are seven contractors with real local crews, verifiable reviews, and the willingness to scope a job honestly.

What Makes Stillwater Gutters Different

Three things shape gutter work in Stillwater specifically. First, the historic overlay: contributing homes typically need half-round profiles in copper or painted aluminum, not modern K-style. HPC review applies to gutter material and color visible from the street. Second, the bluff geography: Stillwater homes on the slopes overlooking the St. Croix have significant grade change between the high and low sides of the lot. Downspout discharge has to be planned, not improvised — water that runs downhill across a bluff lot can ruin a foundation in a hurry. Third, the trees: the original Stillwater neighborhoods have some of the most mature silver maples and elms in the metro. Open gutters fill up fast.

The implication: in Stillwater, gutter sizing, downspout planning, profile selection, and gutter protection all matter more than they would in a flat, low-tree suburb. The right answer for a historic Greeley Street home is rarely the right answer for a Croixwood split-level.

The 7 Best Gutter Companies in Stillwater, MN

1. LeafGuard of Minnesota — Best for One-Piece Covered Gutters

Why they top the list: LeafGuard installs a single, one-piece gutter with the cover already attached at the factory. 4.6-star MN office, consistent feedback about clean installs.

Where they shine: Heavy-tree Stillwater neighborhoods outside the historic overlay. The LeafGuard system genuinely stops most cleaning work, and their warranty explicitly covers clogs.

Where to think twice: Historic district. LeafGuard’s modern profile is rarely HPC-compliant on contributing structures — half-round in painted aluminum or copper is what the HPC typically wants there. Pricing is also 2–3x a traditional 6-inch K-style with a separate cover.

Best for: Stillwater homeowners outside the historic overlay with heavy tree cover.

2. Twin Cities Gutter — Best for Traditional 6-Inch K-Style and Half-Round

Why they’re #2: Focused gutter-only company doing seamless aluminum installs across the metro. They run K-style and half-round profiles, including painted aluminum half-round suitable for some HPC submissions.

Where they shine: Profile flexibility. Most modern gutter companies only do K-style; Twin Cities Gutter actually runs half-round on demand, which matters in Stillwater’s historic district.

Where to think twice: Not a roofing company, so if your roof is also at end-of-life you’ll need a separate roofer to coordinate flashing.

Best for: Stillwater homeowners who need either a clean K-style replacement or HPC-friendly half-round.

3. Gutter Helmet of Minnesota — Best Cover Retrofit

Why they’re #3: Retrofits a louvered cover over your existing gutters. Crews are fast, pricing is competitive.

Where they shine: Cost-effective gutter protection without replacing gutters. About half the price of full replacement plus a cover.

Where to think twice: Heavy ice and historic-district homes (cover modifications often need HPC review in the overlay).

Best for: Stillwater homeowners outside the historic district with sound existing gutters.

4. Gutter Cover MN — Best for Premium Micro-Mesh

Why they’re #4: Stainless micro-mesh covers that keep out smaller debris (maple seeds, pine needles).

Where they shine: Pine-needle problems. Stillwater bluff lots with conifers benefit most.

Where to think twice: Micro-mesh needs an annual hose rinse — low-maintenance, not zero.

Best for: Stillwater homes with conifers nearby, outside the historic overlay.

5. ClearChoice Gutter Cleaning & Repair — Best for Service & Maintenance

Why they’re #5: Handles cleanings, minor repairs, downspout extensions, and the occasional small replacement.

Where they shine: Same-week service. Fair pricing on small jobs.

Where to think twice: They don’t quote larger replacement work or HPC-compliant historic-district installs.

Best for: Stillwater homeowners with a specific repair, leak, or annual cleaning need.

6. All Aspects Exteriors — Best Mid-Sized Generalist

Why they’re #6: Mid-sized exterior contractor handling siding, roofing, and gutters together.

Where they shine: Bundled scopes outside the historic district.

Where to think twice: Not the lowest price on a gutter-only scope. Limited HPC submission experience.

Best for: Stillwater homeowners doing a full exterior remodel outside the overlay.

7. Owl Roofing & Exteriors — Best for Roofing + Gutters Bundled

Why we’re on this list: Owl is a Shoreview-based exterior contractor. Gutters aren’t our standalone specialty. But if you’re getting a new roof from us, adding seamless 6-inch K-style gutters at the same time is the right move. We’ve also handled a small number of historic Stillwater reroof projects (see our Stillwater historic home reroof guide) and understand HPC review on the roofing side.

Where we shine: Roof-and-gutter combo jobs outside the historic district. We get the drip edge right and don’t leave you to chase two warranties at the eave. On bluff lots, we plan downspout discharge so water doesn’t run into the foundation.

Where to think twice: Historic-district half-round installs are not our daily work — Twin Cities Gutter has the profile experience there. We’re also a 35-minute drive from Stillwater.

Best for: Stillwater homeowners replacing roof and gutters together outside the historic district.

Owl’s Side-by-Side Comparison: Stillwater Gutter Companies

Contractor	Best For	Profile Options	Historic-District Friendly	Drive to Stillwater
LeafGuard of MN	Heavy tree cover	One-piece factory	No	40 min
Twin Cities Gutter	K-style + half-round	K-style / half-round	Strong	35 min
Gutter Helmet of MN	Cover retrofits	Louvered cover	Limited	40 min
Gutter Cover MN	Premium micro-mesh	Stainless mesh retrofit	Limited	40 min
ClearChoice	Service & repair	Repairs only	Limited	35 min
All Aspects Exteriors	Bundled exteriors	K-style	Limited	40 min
Owl Roofing	Roof + gutter combo	K-style	Limited	35 min

How to Choose the Right Gutter Company in Stillwater

Step 1: Confirm HPC Status First

If your home is in the historic overlay, gutter profile and color may need HPC review. Half-round in painted aluminum or copper is usually approvable; modern K-style sometimes is not.

Step 2: 5-Inch vs. 6-Inch K-Style

For most Stillwater homes outside the historic district, 6-inch K-style is the right answer. A 6-inch gutter handles roughly 40% more water than a 5-inch — and Stillwater’s heavier modern storms make the difference real.

Step 3: Confirm Seamless Aluminum, Not Sectional

Avoid sectional gutters joined every 10 feet. Each joint is a future leak.

Step 4: Plan the Downspout Discharge for Bluff Lots

Stillwater bluff homes need careful downspout planning. Each downspout should discharge at least 5 feet from the foundation, and on a hillside lot the discharge needs to direct water across the slope, not straight downhill toward the house. A bad downspout plan on a bluff lot is the most common cause of basement seepage in Stillwater.

Frequently Asked Questions

How much do new gutters cost in Stillwater, MN?

For a typical Stillwater home with about 150–200 linear feet of gutters, expect roughly $1,800–$3,200 for seamless 6-inch K-style aluminum, $3,500–$6,000 with a louvered cover system, and $7,500–$12,000 for a full LeafGuard one-piece system. Half-round in painted aluminum runs roughly $4,500–$7,500; copper half-round runs $9,000–$18,000+.

Do gutters need HPC approval in the Stillwater historic district?

Yes, for any contributing structure when the gutter profile or color is visible from the public right-of-way. Material, color, and downspout placement are typically reviewed.

Are gutter covers worth it for Stillwater homes?

For homes outside the historic district with mature trees, yes — Stillwater has some of the heaviest tree cover in the metro. Inside the historic district, cover decisions often need HPC review.

Do gutters need a permit in Stillwater?

Standalone gutter replacement does not typically require a permit in Stillwater outside the historic overlay. Inside the overlay, contributing structures may require HPC review even if no building permit is needed.

Should I replace gutters and roof at the same time?

If both are within 5 years of end-of-life, yes. One mobilization, properly coordinated drip edge, and a single contractor accountable for the eave-to-gutter transition.

Other Stillwater Exterior Guides

• Best Window Installers in Stillwater, MN
• Best Siding Contractors in Stillwater, MN
• Best Roofing Companies in Stillwater, MN
• Reroofing a Stillwater Historic Home: Profile, Color & Material Match

Get a Free Gutter Estimate in Stillwater, MN

Owl Roofing & Exteriors offers free gutter estimates throughout Stillwater outside the historic district, especially for homeowners pairing a roof replacement with new gutters and bluff-lot homeowners who need careful downspout planning. Call (651) 528-8854 or request an estimate online.

Sources: Google reviews verified May 2026 for LeafGuard of Minnesota, Twin Cities Gutter, Gutter Helmet of Minnesota, Gutter Cover MN, ClearChoice Gutter Cleaning, All Aspects Exteriors, and Owl Roofing & Exteriors. GAF on seamless vs. sectional gutters. International Residential Code drip-edge requirements. Stillwater Heritage Preservation Commission.