Best Insurance Agents in Shoreview, MN — Top Local Agencies in 2026

Finding a great insurance agent in Shoreview is more than just getting the lowest rate — it’s about having someone who picks up the phone, explains your coverage clearly, and actually goes to bat for you when something goes wrong. Shoreview is lucky to have several outstanding local agents serving the community. At Owl Roofing, we work closely with insurance agents across the north metro (especially after hail storms and wind events), and we can vouch for how much a good agent matters when your roof is on the line.

Here are the top-rated insurance agents and agencies in Shoreview, MN for 2026.

Best Insurance Agents in Shoreview, MN (2026)

1. Robert Overby — State Farm Insurance

📍 5928 Lexington Ave N, Shoreview, MN 55126
⭐ 5.0 / 422 reviews | 📞 651-784-0010 | boboverby.com

Bob Overby’s State Farm office in Shoreview is about as trusted as it gets — a perfect 5.0 rating across 422 Google reviews is a rare and remarkable achievement. Bob and his team have been serving Shoreview families for decades, offering home, auto, life, and business insurance with a level of attentiveness that makes clients stay for life. Known for always picking up the phone, giving clear explanations, and making the claims process as easy as possible.

What neighbors are saying:

“My wife and I have been State Farm customers for over 4 decades and have worked with Bob Overby’s office for many years. Someone always picks up the phone when we call. Highly recommended!” — Jim Wilson

“We recently switched to Robert Overby State Farm — the process was very easy. They were knowledgeable, patient, and saved us money by bundling our home and auto.” — Judith Drabant

“Bob and his team have always provided great service. They are very friendly and extremely knowledgeable whenever we have questions about our coverage.” — Pat Payne

2. Ryan Hangartner — State Farm Insurance

📍 3999 Rice St Ste 104A, Shoreview, MN 55126
⭐ 4.9 / 515 reviews | 📞 651-486-6999 | insurewithry.com

Ryan Hangartner’s State Farm agency is one of the highest-volume and most-reviewed insurance offices in all of Shoreview, with over 500 Google reviews averaging 4.9 stars. Ryan and his team are known for finding significant savings without sacrificing coverage — many clients report cutting their insurance bills substantially while actually improving their policies. Fast, friendly, and genuinely helpful with all the details.

What neighbors are saying:

“I was floored when I learned the rates they offered were less than half of what I was currently paying. Switching to State Farm was a painless and fast transition.” — Kristina Traynor

“Ryan and his team are great — friendly, professional and quick to resolve any problems. Extremely affordable and they work to find you the best deal!” — Erin Farber

“They’re saving me over $600 annually with more coverage than my last provider. Changing insurances can be some work but they made it easy.” — Hayley Wiesman

3. Preferred Insurance Services Inc

📍 1306 County Rd F West, Arden Hills, MN 55112 (serves Shoreview)
⭐ 4.9 / 143 reviews | 📞 651-255-3500 | preferredmn.com

Preferred Insurance Services is an independent insurance agency just west of Shoreview in Arden Hills, and one of the most respected in the north metro. As an independent broker, they work with multiple carriers to find you the best combination of coverage and price — rather than being locked into one company’s options. They handle home, auto, business, and specialty coverage with a team that’s been serving clients for decades. Ask for Doug Pierro, Brad, Colleen, or Jeff Slage — this team is full of genuine experts.

What neighbors are saying:

“Preferred Insurance is a great company to work with. Ask for Doug Pierro — Doug has been my agent since 1993 and has always taken care of me and always answers his phone.” — Dennis Connors

“Brad & Colleen are the best! They’ve worked hard to ensure we have the best possible coverage at the best possible price.” — Todd McNurlin

“We have so enjoyed working with Jeff Slage at Preferred Insurance. He helped us through an unexpected basement flood and found the best price for our homeowners and car insurance.” — Linda Mischke

4. Joshua Deering — Allstate Insurance

📍 470 Hwy 96 W Ste 100, Shoreview, MN 55126
⭐ 4.7 / 177 reviews | 📞 651-964-6496 | agents.allstate.com

Joshua Deering’s Allstate office brings a different carrier option to Shoreview homeowners — Allstate’s broad product line paired with a local team known for digging deep to find real savings. With 177 reviews and a 4.7-star average, the Deering agency earns consistent praise for knowledgeable agents who take the time to explain every option and make the switch as smooth as possible. Team members Nicole, Jamie, and Julie are frequently mentioned by name.

What neighbors are saying:

“We worked with Nicole Nagle, and she was absolutely amazing! She was able to save us almost $200 a month AND increase our coverage.” — Whitney West

“I worked with Jamie and she knocked it out of the park. She took over an hour to explain the differences between my current policy and what she was offering. Completely worth the switch.” — Megan E.

5. Tim Meyer — State Farm Insurance

📍 891 Hwy 96 W, Shoreview, MN 55126
⭐ 5.0 / 21 reviews | 📞 651-482-1140 | timlmeyer.com

Tim Meyer’s State Farm office has quietly built a perfect 5.0 rating in Shoreview, serving families across multiple generations. Tim’s team is known for patience, thoroughness, and the kind of long-term client relationships that make you feel like more than just a policy number. If you want an agent whose office you can actually walk into, who knows your family’s situation and keeps watch over your coverage over time, Tim Meyer is a standout choice.

What neighbors are saying:

“Tim Meyer has been my parents’ agent as long as I can remember. When I signed on to insure my own vehicles they were very patient and knowledgeable throughout the entire process.” — Michael Burrs

“I have been a customer of the Tim Meyer State Farm Agency for over 20 years. I like the pricing policy and discounts for bundled coverage — they’ve always taken care of me.” — Nancy Wolf

“Kayla was incredibly helpful in navigating our homeowners-to-rental and back-to-homeowners transitions. Yes, it’s as confusing as it sounds — and she made it seamless.” — Rajvi Mehta

6. True Partners Insurance Brokers

📍 4522 Bridge Ct, Shoreview, MN 55126
⭐ 5.0 / 47 reviews | 📞 612-469-7382 | truepartnersinsurance.com

True Partners Insurance Brokers is Shoreview’s go-to resource for Medicare Advantage and health insurance — specifically for clients navigating Medicare options, supplement plans, and coverage transitions. Owners Tom and Jill are known for their personal approach: they’ll come to your home, walk you through all your options without pressure, and help you find the plan that genuinely fits your needs and budget. If you or a family member is approaching Medicare eligibility, True Partners is the first call to make.

What neighbors are saying:

“Tom & Jill are the best. They helped my husband and I find the perfect insurance for us. They’re very personable and willing to come to your house or meet wherever you’re comfortable.” — Vickie

“Tom and Jill came to my parents’ home and gave them a comprehensive presentation of Medicare Advantage options. No pressure, just genuinely helpful guidance.” — Susan Kriesel

“I phoned True Partners when I suddenly found myself without a Medicare advantage plan. They were responsive, clear, and helped me find the right coverage quickly.” — George Merth

A Note on Insurance & Roofing Claims in Shoreview

Shoreview homeowners deal with hail storms, wind damage, and ice dams every year — and when that happens, your insurance agent and your roofing contractor need to work together. At Owl Roofing, we work alongside insurance adjusters regularly and can help document damage, support your claim, and get your roof repaired or replaced with the least friction possible.

A good insurance agent will connect you with contractors they trust. We hope to be on that list.

Are You an Insurance Agent in Shoreview? Let’s Connect.

We love building referral relationships with insurance agents across the north metro. When your clients have roofing, window, gutter, or siding claims, we’ll take great care of them — and we’ll keep you in the loop throughout.

📞 Call or text Owl Roofing: (651) 424-4416
🌐 Get a free estimate: owlroofing.com/contact

Whether you’re a Shoreview insurance agent looking for a trusted roofing referral partner, or a homeowner who needs roofing, windows, gutters, or siding work — Owl Roofing is your north metro neighbor and we’re ready to help.